Our Unfolding Story
In the mid-eighteenth century, the Congregational Church was the established church of the Massachusetts Bay Colony and mandated Sunday religious worship. The Puritans living in the area now known as Paxton, settled around 1748, were residents of either Leicester or Rutland. In order to attend worship services, they had to travel long distances, in constant fear of Native American attacks, to the center of Rutland or Leicester.
After years of petitioning His Majesty King George III’s Great and General Court to form a new district so the settlers could establish a closer church and settle a gospel minister, the bill was finally passed. Governor Francis Bernard signed the legislation on February 12, 1765, authorizing the Parish and District of Paxton, containing four square miles from equal portions of Rutland and Leicester. Because the basis for establishing Paxton rested on a religious necessity, organization became an urgent matter. The first warrant was issued on February 25, 1765, followed by the first town meeting, and, by April 1, approval for building a Meetinghouse was voted. One and one-half acres were donated by Seth Snow, a portion of which became the Old Burial Ground.
Silas Bigelow was called as the first settled minister on May 4, 1767, moving to Paxton from Concord and Shrewsbury and residing on Asnebumskit Hill. He helped in the establishment of the church and was much admired during his short ministry, dying in 1769 at only 30 years of age. Worship services were held in nearby homes until September 3, 1767, when construction of the Meetinghouse was completed, on the Common near where the flag pole now stands. It served as both a religious and municipal center.
In the 1830s, separation of church and state became prevalent, and, on July 14, 1830, the church severed its connection with the town and became the First Parish Church of Paxton. Discussions about moving the Meetinghouse to its present location began in 1834. The town paid $500 to move and repair it, build a belfry, and hang a bell, provided the town would be permitted to conduct business in the building. The move was completed in 1835. A steeple, vestibule, gallery and basement were added, and a 700-pound Paul Revere bell was brought from Boston by oxcart. In 1850, the Masonic clock that hangs in the sanctuary was purchased. The basement was used for municipal purposes until the town hall was built in 1888.
The First Parish Church of Paxton was disbanded in 1894, and the church was incorporated as the First Congregational Church of Paxton. In 1896, Eliza Howe willed her home at 16 West Street to be used as a parsonage for the church, and the chandelier that still graces the sanctuary was given by Deacon Edward Kendall of Cambridge, Massachusetts.
The twentieth century brought continuing growth – and natural disasters: the steeple was destroyed by hurricane in 1938, and the front of the church and the pipe organ were extensively damaged by fire in May, 1969. Repairs were completed soon after each event. Major additions and renovations were made in 1957 and 1988, including a chair lift to facilitate handicapped accessibility. The Grove Street parsonage was purchased in 1965.
Today, First Congregational Church of Paxton continues to thrive as a warm, welcoming, and active faith community. Our historic sanctuary echoes with new life each Sunday at 10am as people gather for meaningful worship, thoughtful conversation, and genuine connection. From community meals and service projects to book groups, choir rehearsals, and seasonal celebrations, the spirit of this place is alive and growing. As we honor our deep roots, we remain focused on living out a faith that is relevant, inclusive, and grounded in love.
